The year has hardly begun and we’ve already witnessed radical shifts throughout society - growing anti-establishment contingencies, women’s rights marches, and the new US administration are some of the major talking points of 2017. Many have called this the ushering of a new era, one where institutions are met with anxiety rather than trust; in such a climate, brands and businesses can play an important role through establishing a distinct POV and by supporting actions that address critical societal issues of the day.
But brand involvement in such issues can sometimes go wrong. One such case is Audi USA, whose recent #DriveProgress commercial was met with much backlash online. The advert speaks of how Audi is committed to “equal pay for equal work” – a noble, necessary cause that has been welcomed with notoriety when supported by other brands and business in the past. This commercial is different.
The ad has garnered over 12 million YouTube views but with a very polarising 45% v 55% ratio of likes to dislikes, and negative comments from disgruntled viewers who threatened to never buy an Audi again.
It would be a real shame if Audi’s bumpy ride (pun intended) in supporting a crucial social cause puts off other brands from following suit. Because, between brands’ reach and influence (and budgets!), they have the potential to be a great power for good in our world.
As we have seen with campaigns over the years from Dove (“Real Beauty”) to Always (“Like a Girl”) to Ben & Jerry’s (“Save Our Swirled”), get it right and you get real brand engagement from people moved by subjects that really matter to them and the world they live in.
What’s interesting in all the noise around Audi is that the company created another ad focused on gender equality in Spain last Christmas that generated significantly more positive feedback (94% likes vs 6% dislikes).
Lesson 1: Build a strong link between your product or business and the social POV
Audi’s somewhat tenuous link between a go-kart race won by a girl could have been so much stronger if they had talked about the shortage of female engineers in their industry. Here is a real issue that they have to resolve that is a manifestation of the social issue. In the Spanish Audi ad, the gender stereotypes that surround the traditionally male-focused motor industry is highlighted through the way the choices of toys for girls and boys are expected to fit socially defined norms.
Lesson 2: Your brand’s POV needs to be clearly backed up by ongoing action
Although the company stated in the ad that “Audi of America is committed to equal pay for equal work,” the fact that this was already a legal requirement of all companies in the US and that only 2 of the 14 members of the Audi US Exec Board are women undermined its POV. This contradiction made it feel like an advertising ploy, rather than a core belief backed up by an ongoing commitment to actions to drive real impact to change the social issue. In today's world people are quick to punish companies and institutions if their endeavours are seen as insincere actions aimed at garnering publicity. They want to see that credible, on-the-ground actions are being taken to tackle society’s prevailing issues.
Lesson 3: Build from a point of credibility
When Coca-Cola first ran its ‘America The Beautiful’ ad during the Super Bowl in 2014, there was much debate about racial diversity in the US. Whilst some of the feedback was extremely negative, the significant majority was positive. However, Coke was building on its credibility in this space having preached that ‘there is more that unites us than divides us’ for many years, which lends more credibility to a stronger and more controversial POV.
Lesson 4: A shared fiction is more valuable than communicating facts
In response to many of the negative comments, the Audi US team responded with a number of facts and figures to back up their case for the pay gap between men and women. These facts were obscured by a debate over how they could be interpreted in different ways. But at the core of the company’s POV is a belief about fairness: Here we are dealing with values, not rational numbers. A belief shared by a group of people is built from a human narrative that people can buy into. Beliefs are not rational arguments – they are intangible. The Spanish Audi spot has no facts – it simply has an inspiring story of a better alternative future that we can buy into.
Lesson 5: Whilst a social cause is usually serious, engagement can be more fun
Social change is a serious matter - but that does not mean that the execution always has to be overly serious. To drive social change, you need to inspire people to join your fight. A little bit of fun and entertainment can make the cause seem more attractive to join. Whilst the Audi Spain ad inspires and energizes, the Audi US ad feels preachy and condescending.
Lesson 6: Choose your enemy carefully
A good POV will normally have opposing sides – that doesn’t mean that you need to totally alienate one of them. In their US ad, Audi clearly created a setup of ‘good’ (girl racer) and ‘bad’ (boy racers); the ad therefore came across as an implicit attack on men. Men clearly felt that given many of the comments written on the YouTube page. In reality, the enemy is the cultural norms and stereotypes. Again, the Spanish ad gets this right by explicitly highlighting that boys also suffer, as they too are restricted in what type of toys they can play with (no dolls allowed).
Our message to brands and businesses is to embrace the opportunity to make a contribution to a better world. Society needs it. Despite Audi US’ experience, people are increasingly looking to brands to step up. But there is a fine line between getting it right and getting it wrong; take the time to think through the details.
To help marketers, insight leaders and changemakers to stay in tune with the diverse female identities of today, we at Innate Motion have published our latest, free ebook, Beyond The Powergirl. By providing an inspiring framework of 16 different future feminine archetypes, we hope you will join the movement to unleash the potential of feminine identities and unlock more potential by building stronger brands, businesses and communities.